Employee DSARs: a practical guide for HR teams

General information, not legal advice. Employment disputes often raise issues beyond data protection, so take advice on your own case. Last checked against ICO guidance on 16 November 2026.

Subject access requests from current and former employees often arrive during a grievance, a disciplinary or after someone leaves, and tend to involve years of email naming colleagues, managers and clients. This guide pulls together what the ICO says about employee SARs and what it means for redaction.

The ICO notes that its SAR Q&As for employers are under review following the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, so check that page for updates.

Recognising an employee SAR

The ICO says a worker can make a SAR verbally or in writing, including by social media, and to any part of the organisation. It does not need to use the words "subject access request". The ICO's examples include "Please send me my HR file" and "Can I have a copy of the emails sent by my manager to HR regarding my verbal warning?" (ICO: SAR Q&As for employers). Make sure line managers know to pass these on straight away, because the one-month clock is already running (our DSAR deadline guide).

Grievances, tribunals and settlement agreements

Three points from the ICO's employer guidance come up again and again:

  • A grievance or tribunal does not stop a SAR. You cannot simply refuse because the worker is in a grievance or tribunal process and you think they want the information for litigation. If you withhold, you must show which exemption applies and why.
  • A tribunal bundle is not a SAR response. The ICO says documents disclosed in litigation may not contain all of the worker's personal information, and may have gone to their representative rather than to them.
  • Settlement and non-disclosure agreements do not waive the right. The ICO says the right of access cannot be overridden by such an agreement, and a term limiting it is likely to be unenforceable.

Clarifying a broad request

If you hold a lot of information about a long-serving worker, the ICO says you can ask them to specify what they want, and the time limit pauses until they reply. But if they still want everything, you should carry out reasonable searches (ICO: Can we clarify the request?).

Emails: the bulk of most employee DSARs

The ICO's position on emails is the key to keeping an employee DSAR proportionate (ICO: information contained in emails):

  • Being copied into an email does not make its whole content the worker's personal information.
  • An email about a business matter may still contain their personal information.
  • Their name and email address are their personal information.
  • An email in a "Deleted items" folder has not been deleted.

The ICO gives an example of an employee copied into 2,000 emails whose content does not otherwise relate to them. You could tell them their name and email address appear on those 2,000 emails and disclose those details, or provide one redacted email as a sample. Where any email's content does relate to them, you must provide it, redacted if necessary. Our guide to redacting emails for a DSAR covers the practical side.

The ICO also says searches should cover social media and chat used for business, such as Teams or WhatsApp.

Colleagues, witnesses and whistleblowers

Employee files are full of other people. The ICO's employer guidance applies the third-party test (consent, or whether disclosure is reasonable without it) and adds that, in a work context, a person's seniority and role are relevant. It is generally more likely to be reasonable to disclose information about an employee acting in a professional capacity (ICO: SAR Q&As for employers).

The ICO's examples include:

  • Pay review notes. An employer disclosed the notes about the worker's own performance but redacted the comparisons with named colleagues.
  • Witness statements. Where statements were taken on the basis of confidentiality and redaction would not hide who wrote them, the employer decided not to disclose them.
  • Whistleblowing reports. These need the requester's rights balanced against the whistleblower's, including protection under the Public Interest Disclosure Act 1998.

Asking a colleague for consent is not always appropriate. The ICO points out that an employee may not be able to consent freely to their employer because of the imbalance of power (ICO: information about other people).

Exemptions common in HR files

Besides third-party data, the ICO's employer guidance discusses confidential references, legal professional privilege (for example, advice from your solicitors about the worker), crime and taxation (for example, an ongoing fraud investigation), management information and negotiations with the requester. See our guide to DSAR exemptions.

Keep a record

The ICO says you should record what you decided about third-party information and why (ICO: information about other people), and document your reasons for any exemption. In an employment dispute, that record may be examined later.

Where Fairleaf fits

Fairleaf Disclosure prepares redacted disclosure packs for HR teams, DPOs and solicitors. For an employee DSAR, our software proposes redactions for colleagues', managers' and clients' personal data, flags passages that may fall under an exemption and builds one bookmarked pack with a schedule of every document, an exemption log and a search record. Your HR team, DPO or solicitor reviews every proposed redaction and makes the final decisions. See what goes in a disclosure pack.

Frequently asked questions

Do we have to respond to a DSAR from a former employee?

Yes. The right of access gives a person the right to a copy of the personal information you hold about them (ICO: What is the right of access?). Leaving your employment does not end that right, and the usual time limits apply.

Can we refuse a DSAR because the employee has raised a tribunal claim?

No. The ICO says you cannot simply refuse because a worker is in a tribunal or grievance process. You must show which exemption applies to anything you withhold.

Do we have to disclose every email the employee was copied into?

Not necessarily. The ICO says being a recipient does not make the whole email their personal information. You must consider what in each email relates to them, and their name and email address must be disclosed.

See a full example pack

We will email you a complete disclosure pack built from a synthetic mailbox: the redacted documents, the schedule, the exemption log and the search record. It is free and there is no obligation.

Request the example packGet the pack (opens your email app)

hello@fairleaf.co.uk

Please do not send us any real personal data or request material by email. We will arrange a secure route if you go ahead.

Example redacted email from a Fairleaf disclosure pack. Third-party names are covered by black boxes marked TP; the requester's own details stay visible. Synthetic data. Example pack, synthetic data

Fairleaf does not give legal advice. Our clients remain responsible for their disclosure decisions.