DSAR exemptions explained: what UK organisations can withhold

General information, not legal advice. Whether an exemption applies depends on the facts of each request, and the decision is your organisation's. Last checked against ICO guidance on 16 November 2026.

Most UK subject access exemptions sit in Schedule 2 of the Data Protection Act 2018. They allow an organisation to withhold some, or occasionally all, of the information a requester would otherwise receive. This guide summarises the ones that come up most often in DSARs and SARs, with links to the ICO's guidance and the legislation.

How exemptions work

The ICO's guidance on exemptions for SARs makes a few general points that apply to all of them (ICO: What exemptions are relevant for SARs?):

  • Case by case. You cannot routinely rely on exemptions or apply them in a blanket fashion.
  • Different types. Some apply because of the nature of the information (for example, a confidential reference). Others apply only to the extent that disclosure would be likely to prejudice a purpose.
  • Sometimes optional. Where an exemption applies, you may sometimes be obliged to rely on it, for example where disclosure would break another law. In other cases, you can choose.
  • Document it. You should document your reasons for relying on an exemption and be able to justify it.

Where an exemption depends on prejudice, the ICO says you should identify the specific prejudice, link it clearly to the disclosure and show it is real and of substance (ICO: What does prejudice mean?).

Information about other people (TP)

You do not have to disclose information that would identify another person unless they consent, or it is reasonable to disclose it without their consent (DPA 2018, Schedule 2, paragraph 16). Factors include the type of information, any duty of confidentiality, the steps taken to seek consent, whether the person can consent, and any refusal (ICO: information about other people).

The same ICO page covers special rules for some health, education and social work staff. Sensitive information about another person, such as their health, is assessed under the same test, and our pack codes it separately (SC) so your reviewer can see it at a glance.

Legal professional privilege (LPP)

Personal information is exempt if a claim to legal professional privilege could be maintained in legal proceedings, or if a professional legal adviser owes a duty of confidentiality to their client about it (DPA 2018, Schedule 2, paragraph 19).

The ICO explains that this covers litigation privilege and legal advice privilege (with an equivalent concept in Scotland), only for confidential communications made for the relevant purpose, and not to everything a law firm processes (ICO: Legal professional privilege).

Management information (MF)

Personal information processed for management forecasting or management planning is exempt to the extent that disclosure would be likely to prejudice the conduct of the business or activity (DPA 2018, Schedule 2, paragraph 22). The ICO says you should be able to show the information is actually being used for that purpose (ICO: Management information). The ICO's examples include unannounced plans for a reshuffle that may involve redundancies. It also gives a counter-example: senior managers' discussions about dismissing one particular employee were about that individual, not the organisation's wider strategy, so the exemption did not apply.

Negotiations with the requester

Records of your intentions in negotiations with the requester are exempt, to the extent that disclosure would be likely to prejudice those negotiations (DPA 2018, Schedule 2, paragraph 23 and ICO: Negotiations with the requester). The ICO's example is an insurer's record of its position on a disputed claim.

Confidential references (CR)

A reference given in confidence for someone's education, training, employment, volunteering, appointment to office or provision of a service is exempt (DPA 2018, Schedule 2, paragraph 24). The ICO says this applies whether you gave or received the reference, but only to references actually given in confidence (ICO: Confidential references).

Crime and taxation

Information processed for preventing or detecting crime, apprehending or prosecuting offenders, or assessing or collecting tax is exempt to the extent that disclosure would be likely to prejudice those purposes (DPA 2018, Schedule 2, paragraph 2). The ICO's employer guidance gives the example of withholding material about an ongoing fraud investigation (ICO: SAR Q&As for employers).

Manifestly unfounded or excessive requests

The ICO says you can refuse a SAR wholly or partly, or charge a reasonable fee, if it is manifestly unfounded or excessive, but the threshold is high (ICO: manifestly unfounded or excessive).

Other exemptions

The ICO lists further exemptions, such as regulatory functions, research, and exam scripts and marks. Its guide to the data protection exemptions covers these.

If you withhold information

If you refuse to comply with a request, in whole or part, the ICO says you must tell the person the reasons, their right to complain to you as the controller, their right to complain to the ICO, and their ability to seek to enforce their rights through the courts. Where telling them which exemption you used would itself cause prejudice, your explanation can be more general (ICO: What do we need to do if we refuse?).

Where Fairleaf fits

In a Fairleaf Disclosure pack, our software flags passages that may fall under an exemption and gives each proposed redaction a code (TP, SC, LPP, MF, CR) linked to the relevant provision of the UK GDPR or the Data Protection Act 2018. The exemption log records what was proposed and on what basis, so your reviewer can check it. Whether an exemption applies is your decision, not ours. See what goes in a disclosure pack.

Frequently asked questions

Is an email marked "confidential" exempt from a DSAR?

Not automatically. The ICO says a duty of confidence does not arise merely because something is marked confidential, although the marking may indicate an expectation of confidence. Confidentiality is a factor in the third-party test, not a standalone exemption.

Can we withhold everything because the requester is taking us to a tribunal?

No. The ICO's employer guidance says you cannot refuse simply because someone is in a grievance or tribunal process. If you withhold information, you must show which exemption applies and why.

See a full example pack

We will email you a complete disclosure pack built from a synthetic mailbox: the redacted documents, the schedule, the exemption log and the search record. It is free and there is no obligation.

Request the example packGet the pack (opens your email app)

hello@fairleaf.co.uk

Please do not send us any real personal data or request material by email. We will arrange a secure route if you go ahead.

Example redacted email from a Fairleaf disclosure pack. Third-party names are covered by black boxes marked TP; the requester's own details stay visible. Synthetic data. Example pack, synthetic data

Fairleaf does not give legal advice. Our clients remain responsible for their disclosure decisions.