What can be redacted in a subject access request?
General information, not legal advice. Every disclosure decision in a request is your organisation's call. Last checked against ICO guidance on 16 November 2026.
A subject access request (SAR, often called a DSAR) gives a person the right to a copy of their own personal information. Redaction is how you give them that copy without handing over things they are not entitled to. This guide sets out what UK organisations commonly redact or withhold, and what has to stay in.
Start from what the requester is entitled to
The right of access covers the requester's own personal information, confirmation that you are processing it, and supplementary information such as your purposes, recipients and retention periods (ICO: What is the right of access?).
Two points follow from this:
- You are providing information, not documents. The ICO says that because you are obliged to provide information rather than documents, you could delete names or redact documents where the third party's information is not part of what was requested (ICO: information about other people).
- Context still matters. The ICO also says a response should give enough context to be intelligible, and that it may often be better to leave information in unless an exemption covers it (ICO: How can we supply information to the requester?).
Redaction is about removing what you can justify removing, not as much as possible.
Information about other people
This is the most common reason for a redaction. You do not have to provide information that would reveal another person unless that person has consented, or it is reasonable to disclose it without their consent (Data Protection Act 2018, Schedule 2, paragraph 16).
The ICO calls this the "rights of others" exemption and suggests a three-step approach (ICO: information about other people):
- Can you comply without revealing the other person? Think about what the requester already knows. A redacted name may not hide someone if the context gives them away.
- Has the other person consented? If they have, you must disclose. You are not obliged to ask, and asking may not be appropriate, for example where there is an imbalance of power such as an employer asking its own employee.
- Is it reasonable to disclose without consent? Factors include the type of information, any duty of confidentiality, the steps you took to seek consent, whether the person can consent, and any refusal.
The ICO adds that information about a member of staff acting in the course of their duties, whom the requester knows well, is more likely to be disclosed than information about an anonymous person. If you withhold third-party information, you must still provide as much of the requested information as you can, and you should record what you decided and why.
Information covered by another exemption
The Data Protection Act 2018 contains other exemptions that can justify withholding or redacting some information. The ICO lists those most likely to apply to SARs, including legal professional privilege, management information, negotiations with the requester, confidential references and crime and taxation (ICO: What exemptions are relevant for SARs?).
The ICO is clear that exemptions must be considered case by case, cannot be applied routinely or in a blanket fashion, and that you should document your reasons. Our guide to DSAR exemptions explains the common ones in more detail.
Information that is not the requester's personal data
A document can mix the requester's data, other people's data and information that is not personal at all. The ICO says the right of access only applies to the personal information in an email that relates to the requester, so you may need to disclose only part of it (ICO: information contained in emails). Equally, an email about a business matter may still contain the requester's personal information.
What should usually stay in
- The requester's own personal information, unless an exemption applies to it.
- Supplementary information such as purposes, categories of recipients and retention, which the ICO says you must provide in addition to the copy (ICO: What is the right of access?).
- Enough context for the requester to understand what each extract is.
Over-redacting is a risk too: stripping out information the person is entitled to leaves the response incomplete.
Make the redaction itself secure
Deciding what to redact is half the job. The ICO's guidance on disclosing documents securely warns that covering text with a black rectangle can leave it recoverable, and says you should redact from a copy, check documents before disclosure, and keep a record of who redacted what, when and why (ICO: avoiding an accidental breach when redacting). Our guide on redacting emails for a DSAR covers this in practice.
Where Fairleaf fits
Fairleaf Disclosure prepares redacted disclosure packs for UK organisations. Our software proposes redactions for other people's personal data, flags passages that may fall under an exemption and builds the pack. Each proposed redaction carries a short code, such as TP for third-party personal data or LPP for legal professional privilege, that matches the redaction schedule and the exemption log. You review every proposed redaction and make the final call. See what goes in a disclosure pack.
Frequently asked questions
Can we redact names of colleagues in a DSAR?
Sometimes. A colleague's name is their personal data, so the rights of others test applies: consent, or whether it is reasonable to disclose without it. The ICO says information about staff acting in their professional role, whom the requester knows, is more likely to be disclosed. It is a decision for each case.
Do we have to ask third parties for consent before disclosing their information?
No. The ICO says you are not obliged to ask for consent, and in some situations it may not be appropriate. If you do not have consent, you still need to decide whether disclosure is reasonable without it.
Should we tell the requester we have redacted information?
Where possible, yes. The ICO says you should be transparent about your reasons for withholding information, unless saying so would itself prejudice the purpose of the exemption (ICO: What exemptions are relevant for SARs?).